Highlights

31 March 2023

Radaelli Under Fire: Giuseppe Perez

This is the sixth article in the 'Radaelli Under Fire' series. Click here to return to the introduction and view the other entries in the series.

Just as the Radaellian question appeared to fading from the minds of the public press, in comes another commentator. After receiving multiple public requests to provide his opinion on the matter (one of which we saw in the previous article), the highly respected Neapolitan master Giuseppe Perez responds to the call with a detailed critique focused solely on Radaelli's sword method. The booklet, entitled Il sistema di spada Radaelli giudicato dall'arte della scherma ('The Radaelli sword system judged by the art of fencing') was published in 1878, and although it only deals with the Radaellian sword material, it is the longest of the works in this series.1 A copy of the original can be read here in the Corble Collection at KU Leuven.

***Click here to read the translation***

Similarly to Forte, Perez places Radaelli's method in contrast with the 'classical Italian school', but also takes this comparison a step further by citing the Marchionni's treatise on the mixed school as well as French authors to demonstrate how often Radaelli deviates from both the Italian and French traditions, thus calling into question how 'mixed' his system is, as opposed to being a pure invention of Radaelli himself. Perez shows himself to be well-read in fencing literature, and this knowledge leads to a very rigorous and laudable critique; however, whilst the Radaellian sword method deserved much of this criticism, Perez's many comparisons to Marchionni may be understating the diversity of the mixed school throughout much of the 19th century, and many of his insightful remarks are let down by nit-picking on terminology. The 10-page long quotation of Rosaroll & Grisetti's treatise in the section on the bout is also, in my view, rather excessive.

Giuseppe Perez was born around the year 1830, possibly in Naples, and was brought up in fencing from a young age under his father, Onofrio Perez, who had studied under Massimino Pepe (for some reason Perez gives his name as 'Anassimena Pepe') and Giuseppe Morbilli, two of the most renowned Neapolitan fencers from the first half of the 19th century. In 1860 he left Naples and moved to Cuneo, where he enlisted in the 1st Bersaglieri regiment. Here at the local military garrison Perez continued his fencing education, learning French foil from Colonel Maffi and sabre from a Polish immigrant named Stojoscki, who was said to specialise in false edge cuts. A few months later he joined Garibaldi's campaign in southern Italy as the fencing master of the Hungarian Legion, learning sabre fencing from a Hungarian fencer named Yessenschi.2

From 1864 to 1867 he was an assistant fencing master at the Modena military school alongside the famed Cesare Enrichetti. From here he moved to Verona and opened up his own fencing hall, also teaching fencing to the local military regiments for several years, even after regiments were no longer allowed to hire civilian fencing masters. In 1869 he founded a successful fencing equipment manufacturer, which was still in operation at least until the 1940s. In the last decade of his life Perez was a regular contributor to several sporting and fencing-focused magazines, writing about various topics such as standardising Italian fencing terminology, the declining standard of competitive fencing, and comparisons of the French and Italian schools of foil. He died in Verona in March 1894.


*******

1 Giuseppe Perez, Il sistema di spada Radaelli giudicato dall'arte della scherma (Verona: Gaetano Franchini, 1878).
2 "Giuseppe Perez," Scherma Italiana, 15 February 1891, 19–20; Liberato De Amici, "Biografie di schermitori illustri: Giuseppe Perez," Baiardo: periodico schermistico bimensile, 8 September 1892, 61–2; Jacopo Gelli, Scherma Italiana, 15 March 1894, 22–3.

No comments:

Post a Comment